Judy vs. Bench
Human bookkeepers at 10x the price — with a reliability chapter worth knowing.
Bench built a real business around human bookkeepers handling your cleanup work monthly — and for businesses drowning in disorganized receipts, that model makes sense. But Bench shut down abruptly in December 2024 and relaunched under new ownership in January 2025, which raised real questions about stability. If you're a solo LLC with straightforward monthly transactions and want real-time access to your numbers, the math and workflow tell a different story.
What Bench does well
Bench's core strength is genuine: a human bookkeeper actually reviews and cleans your books, which is invaluable if you're catching up on years of messy records or need a CPA-ready hand-off. Their tax preparation add-on with CPAs is also a real differentiator for founders who want one vendor handling both compliance and cleanup.
Where Judy wins
Judy wins on speed, cost, and real-time insight. At $29/month, you're looking at a 10x price difference for comparable single-member LLC coverage. Your transactions are categorized weekly (not monthly), and you can ask financial questions anytime in chat instead of waiting for a scheduled monthly review through a portal. Your data lives in an isolated SQLite ledger that you always control and can export — no vendor lock-in, and no risk of waking up locked out of your own books.
Side by side
| Bench | Judy | |
|---|---|---|
| Price | $299–$499/month | $29/month |
| Setup | Onboarding call + document collection | 60-second bank connection |
| Categorization | Human bookkeeper (monthly) | AI (weekly, automated) |
| Interface | Portal + assigned bookkeeper | Chat where you already work |
| Real-time questions | No — scheduled monthly review | Yes — ask anytime |
| Reliability | Shut down Dec 2024, relaunched Jan 2025 | Continuous Litestream backup to R2 |
Which is right for you?
Choose Bench if…
Choose Bench if you're catching up on multiple years of disorganized bookkeeping and can afford $299+/month for human expertise, or if you need a CPA-coordinated tax prep workflow and want to delegate the entire relationship to one firm.
Choose Judy if…
Choose Judy if you're a solo LLC with regular monthly transactions, want real-time visibility into your P&L, and need to ask financial questions on your own timeline — not on someone else's monthly schedule.
Try Judy free — no credit card required
Connect your bank and get a free 30-day audit — every transaction categorized to the right Schedule C line before you pay a cent.
Run your free audit